Contact Me for a Free Consultation (941) 257-5003


Search - Expectation of Privacy - Motion to Suppress Granted

Posted by John P. Rutkowski | Aug 26, 2019 | 0 Comments

Criminal law -- Search and seizure -- Video surveillance -- Warrant requirements -- Minimization -- Defendant recorded on video surveillance authorized by search warrant while engaging in illegal sexual activity in massage room of commercial spa. Discussion of Fourth Amendment issues related to surreptitious video surveillance. Motion to suppress all evidence obtained against defendant through and in connection with search warrant is granted where search warrant was not sufficiently precise so as to minimize the recording of activities not related to the crimes under investigation, and minimization techniques were not sufficiently employed. Failing to consider and include instructions on minimizing the impact on women clients of the spa through a highly intrusive law enforcement technique in a setting with a high legitimate expectation of privacy was a serious flaw in the search warrant, especially considering that search warrant did not allege that women were seeking illegal contact. Omission of any minimization techniques or directives as to how monitors should respond when viewing male clients receiving lawful services or male clients when no probable cause can be established was also a serious flaw in search warrant. Minimization techniques employed by law enforcement did not satisfy constitutional requirements.


About the Author

John P. Rutkowski

Mr. Rutkowski has been practicing law for the past twenty-five years. Prior to going to law school Mr. Rutkowski served as a deputy sheriff before retiring to attend law school. Upon graduating law school Mr. Rutkowski served as a prosecutor in Florida before going in to private practice and representing clients in three states.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact us

John P. Rutkowski, Attorney at Law, firm represents clients in the area of driving under the influence, boating under the influence, Criminal & Civil Traffic Offenses. Contact me today for a free telephone consultation.